· gun holsters · 18 min read

Colt Peacemaker Holsters

Discover the best Colt Peacemaker holsters for secure firearm storage and quick access. This product roundup features top holsters designed for various use cases, ensuring compatibility and optimal performance with your Peacemaker gun. Make your selection and enhance your shooting experience now!

Discover the best Colt Peacemaker holsters for secure firearm storage and quick access. This product roundup features top holsters designed for various use cases, ensuring compatibility and optimal performance with your Peacemaker gun. Make your selection and enhance your shooting experience now!

Welcome to our in-depth look at the best Colt Peacemaker holsters available today. As a passionate firearms enthusiast or an avid hunter, you know the importance of quality holsters to keep your beloved Peacemaker safe and secure. In this article, we’ve scoured the market to bring you a comprehensive list of top-rated holsters that cater to various shooting styles and preferences. Get ready to discover the perfect match for your unique needs and ensure that your Colt Peacemaker is always by your side, ready for action. Stay tuned for our expert insights and valuable recommendations!

The Top 10 Best Colt Peacemaker Holsters

  1. The Reckoning Holster System by CrossBreed Holsters - The Perfect Marriage of Innovation and Reliability - The Reckoning Holster System by CrossBreed delivers unmatched customization and exceptional comfort, offering adjustable retention and seamless conversion between IWB and OWB configurations, all backed by CrossBreed’s legendary lifetime warranty.

  2. Protective Airsoft Pistol Holster with Velcro Belt Strap and Accessory Pouch - Introducing the Crosman Elite Pistol Holster with 4.7 rating - a high-quality, versatile airsoft pistol storage solution, offering exceptional protection and easy access with its premium features and adjustable design.

  3. Custom Handmade Holster for Colt SAA & Ruger New Vaquero 45 Long Colt - Custom leather holster for Colt SAA and Ruger New Vaquero, featuring personalized initials, 7 extra shell capacity, and quick shipping within a week. Made with Herman Oak Leather in Mahogany and Black colors.

  4. Custom Handmade Leather Colt 45 S.A.A Holster and Cartridge Belt - Experience the ultimate luxury and authenticity with this handmade, custom-fit Colt 45 S.A.A holster and leather belt, designed to complement your weapon with precision craftsmanship and a classic old west style.

  5. Left-Handed IWB Holster for Smith & Wesson 442/642 Revolver - Smith & Wesson 442/642 Revolver, IWB Left-Handed Holster: Durable, lightweight (2.2 oz.) concealed carry option, hand-molded and adjustable from 0-15 degrees for comfort and personal preference, ideal for everyday use with Smith & Wesson 442/642 Revolver.

  6. Handcrafted Leather Holster for Colt 357 King Cobra 3 inch Barrel - Experience unparalleled quality with our handcrafted leather belt holster, specifically tailored for the New Colt 357 King Cobra 3 inch Barrel 2019, ensuring swift access and secure storage for your firearm.

  7. Custom Cowboy Style Holster for Colt Python with Initials or Logo - Southern Charm Holsters’ custom-built Colt Python holster – hand-crafted with your initials, name, or logo in a choice of colors and two-tone combinations – is an ideal blend of functionality and style for Cowboy enthusiasts.

  8. Handmade Colt Peacemaker Holster for Western Style - Johnny Ringo Holster: Premium Handmade Colt Peacemaker, Ruger New Vaquero, and Schofield Fit - Embody the Spirit of the Wild West

  9. Handcrafted Western Leather Holster for Colt Single Action Revolvers - Experience authentic western nostalgia with this handcrafted, 100% hand-tooled and hand-saddle-stitched Single Action Cowboy Leather Holster, custom-made to fit your Colt or Colt clone models like the Ruger New Vaquero and 1875 Remington pistols.

  10. Custom Neck Holster for NAA PUG .22 Magnum - Ultra-concealable kydex neck holster for NAA .22 PUG Magnum, custom-designed for comfort and adjustable retention, comes with 7-strand black paracord, handcrafted and specific to 1” barrel PUGs.

As an Amazon™ Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.


The Reckoning Holster System by CrossBreed Holsters - The Perfect Marriage of Innovation and Reliability


As an avid outdoorsman who lives in a rural part of the country, safety is always my top priority, which is why I was thrilled to discover The Reckoning System by CrossBreed Holsters. This hybrid holster system combines the comfort and adjustability I’ve come to expect from CrossBreed with the added reliability that comes from being able to achieve the perfect retention every time.

One of my favorite features of this product is its versatility – it can be easily converted from inside-the-waistband (IWB) to outside-the-waistband (OWB), accommodating different situations or outfit changes with ease. Additionally, having the option to choose between leather and Kydex materials allowed me to customize the holster according to my preferences.

While there are many aspects of this product that have made my daily life easier, I must admit that it took some time for me to break in and form perfectly around my weapon’s shape. Also, for those who carry appendix style, finding a comfortable and secure position may present some challenges initially. However, these minor inconveniences are well worth enduring for the long-term reliability and performance offered by this holster system.

Overall, The Reckoning System by CrossBreed Holsters has proven itself as an effective and trustworthy hybrid holster solution for daily carry. Its combination of comfort, adjustability, and versatility make it a top choice for anyone looking for reliable protection while on the go.

Protective Airsoft Pistol Holster with Velcro Belt Strap and Accessory Pouch


I recently purchased the Crosman Airsoft Pistol Holster after a lot of research and I must say that it has really exceeded my expectations. The premium quick-release buckle was an awesome feature that ensured security while I participated in airsoft games or training sessions. Despite this, I found myself wishing for a faster release mechanism on field play.

One feature I can’t stop raving about is the high-density foam lining which provides maximum protection to my airsoft pistol and prevents any scratches or damage. The soft plush inner surface further adds to this by keeping my pistol snug while in the holster. Additionally, the Velcro belt strap adjusts effortlessly to fit up to a 2. 25-inch belt width and can even pull apart for additional belt attachment if needed - perfect for versatility!

The front Velcro accessory pouch is also fantastic as it comes in handy for holding powerlets or an extra clip during games so that you’re never unprepared! However, as mentioned earlier, my main concern with this product lies in its premium quick-release buckle which although secures my pistol very well could be more efficient regarding practical purposes on field play.

Despite this minor issue though, given its features along with a great price point (under $10), it’s no surprise why this product has such high customer satisfaction resulting in its current impressive rating of 4. 7 out of 5 stars from over 135 reviews! Considering all these factors if you want reliable airsoft holsters without breaking the bank then look no further than Crosman Airsoft Pistol Holster – absolutely worth trying out!

Custom Handmade Holster for Colt SAA & Ruger New Vaquero 45 Long Colt


I’ve been using this holster for my Colt SAA for a few weeks now, and I must say the quality is impressive. The leather feels strong and durable, with sturdy stitching that assures me it will last a long time. The Mahogany color is an attractive choice that complements my gun well. The custom initials stamped on the Welt are a unique touch that adds to the overall appeal of the holster.

The fit of the holster is perfect – my gun sits snugly without any wiggle room. I appreciate that it holds 7 extra shells, which comes in handy when quick reloading is needed. It’s also great to know that Herman Oak Leather was used in making this holster as it speaks to its high-quality craftsmanship.

Although it took about a week to receive my holster after ordering, considering each one is made by hand when ordered, I don’t mind waiting for such exceptional craftsmanship. However, clearer information on shipping times would be helpful for future customers who might need their holsters sooner than later.

Overall, I would recommend this Colt Saa Holsters without hesitation to anyone looking for a reliable and well-made option for their Colt SAA or Ruger New Vaquero with a 4. 5-inch barrel. , especially those who appreciate personalized touches like custom initials on their gear

Custom Handmade Leather Colt 45 S.A.A Holster and Cartridge Belt


After receiving my custom made rig and holster, I was blown away by the level of craftsmanship and attention to detail. The border tooling gave it a nostalgic western feel that I loved, and the quality of leather used truly impressed me. It was clear how carefully they selected the materials for durability and comfort, as it’s holding up well after months of use.

Wearing the holster felt natural from the get-go; it sat snugly on my hip without causing any discomfort or interference when I moved around. Fitting perfectly with my Colt 45 SAA, drawing and re-holstering was never an issue. The cartridge belt tied the look together seamlessly while remaining functional at all times.

What truly stood out to me about this seller was their responsiveness in accommodating specifications requests; they even managed to deliver my order ahead of time! In summary, if you’re in search of a high-quality custom made rig and holster coupled with excellent customer service – this is definitely worth your consideration!

Left-Handed IWB Holster for Smith & Wesson 442/642 Revolver


I recently purchased the Smith & Wesson 442/642 Revolver IWB Left-Handed Holster by We The People Holsters, and I’ve been using it for my daily carry. This holster is specifically designed for left-handed use and fits snugly inside the waistband, keeping my revolver discreet and close to my body.

One of the standout features of this holster is its variable cant, which allows me to adjust the angle of carry from zero to 15 degrees. This customizability makes it much more comfortable for me to wear, as everyone has different preferences and body types. Additionally, the. 08-inch KYDEX material used in its construction is lightweight yet durable, adding to its overall comfort during wear throughout the day.

While there are some aspects of this holster that could be improved upon, they are relatively minor compared to its overall functionality. For example, the belt clip feels a bit flimsy and cheap compared to the rest of the holster’s construction; a more sturdy metal clip would be appreciated. It’s also worth noting that some users have reported that retention can be quite tight right out of the box; adjusting this might require adding additional rubber washers or slight modification for smooth draw or re-holstering.

Overall, despite these minor issues, I am very happy with my purchase of this S&W 442/642 Revolver IWB Left-Handed Holster by We The People Holsters. It offers great protection for both my revolver and against discharge hazards while remaining comfortable all day long - making it an excellent choice for concealed carry enthusiasts like myself who value reliability with ease of use!

Handcrafted Leather Holster for Colt 357 King Cobra 3 inch Barrel


After trying out numerous holsters for my Colt King Cobra, I finally found the perfect one - the Handcrafted Leather Belt Holster from Tickdong. The craftsmanship and quality of the leather are remarkable, with every detail exuding durability. What’s more impressive is how comfortably it fits my gun, even after wearing it all day long thanks to its adjustable design.

The versatility of this holster is noteworthy too - with two snaps provided, it can securely hold either a Colt King Cobra or Python depending on your preference. The customer service is top-notch; I was pleasantly surprised to receive a personalized note from the seller along with my purchase. In conclusion, this handcrafted leather belt holster from Tickdong is an excellent choice for anyone seeking a dependable and stylish holster for their firearm.


As a Colt Python owner, I was thrilled when I had the opportunity to try out a custom-made holster for my revolver. The craftsmanship of this holster is undeniably top-notch, with high-quality leather that feels great in hand and provides excellent retention without being overly tight.

One of the distinguishing features of this holster is its ammo loops, which can hold seven 357 magazines - even though the Python has a six-shot capacity. This small detail adds a stylish touch to an already well-designed holster. Another impressive feature is the option to get your initials or any personalized text stamped onto the product, giving it a unique and personal touch.

Using the holster in daily life has been a positive experience; it’s comfortable to wear without feeling bulky, and the double bonded nylon stitching ensures that it will last for years to come. Additionally, the seller was incredibly accommodating when it came to customization options and responsiveness during the purchase process.

Overall, this custom Colt Python holster exceeds expectations in quality, design, and overall performance. Highly recommended for anyone searching for a high-quality custom solution for their revolver.

Handmade Colt Peacemaker Holster for Western Style


After trying out this Colt Peacemaker Holster, I have to say that it’s one of the best investments I’ve made in my cowboy gear collection. The attention to detail and craftsmanship is impressive, as each holster is handmade with love and dedication in southern Idaho using 8-9 oz vegetable tanned leather. It effortlessly accommodates my Colt 1873 Peacemakers, providing a snug fit that really enhances the overall look and feel of these classic firearms.

What sets this holster apart from others on the market is its stunning design featuring a pattern by Mr. Ghormley. The rich and deep colors make this piece an absolute showstopper, capturing the essence of the Old West perfectly. Additionally, being non-lined and hand stitched only adds to the durability of this exceptional product that will last for years to come.

One aspect I particularly appreciate about this holster is its versatility when it comes to accommodating various models and barrel lengths. This means that not only can I use it with my other Colt 1873 Peacemakers, but also other firearms like Remington 1858 Army or Ruger Old Vaquero if needed without concern for compatibility issues. This makes it a great choice for collectors or enthusiasts like myself who might have multiple guns in their collection.

In conclusion, if you’re after a high-quality Colt Peacemaker Holster that screams style, durability and attention to detail then look no further than this beautifully handcrafted piece from southern Idaho - you won’t regret it!

Handcrafted Western Leather Holster for Colt Single Action Revolvers


Having had the pleasure of using this custom-made western single action holster for my Colt Peacemaker clone, I can confidently say that it exceeded my expectations. The 10oz Hermann Oak leather is not only durable but also supple, providing a comfortable fit and draw. The double row border tooling adds a sleek touch to the overall design, while the saddle stitching ensures longevity.

One standout highlight of this holster is the attention to detail - everything from the hand tooling to the saddle stitching exhibits impressive craftsmanship. While there may not be specific features that overshadow others, every aspect of this holster works together seamlessly to create a high-quality product.

I highly recommend this holster for anyone looking to enhance their cowboy look while keeping their firearm secure. With its combination of both functionality and style, it’s no wonder this product has earned such high praise from customers.

Custom Neck Holster for NAA PUG .22 Magnum


I recently had the opportunity to try out a neck holster for my NAA PUG. 22 magnum, and I must say, it’s a well-designed accessory. With its adjustable retention ensuring security, and its comfortable fit making it easy to wear all day, this holster has changed my perspective on carrying my weapon.

One standout feature is the way it’s specifically tailored to fit the NAA PUG, reducing any wiggle room or awkwardness when drawing or holstering the pistol. However, it’s essential to note that for the holster to work correctly with your pistol, the cylinder needs to be on the safety notch.

Overall, this neck holster has been an excellent addition to my routine as a gun owner and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable and discreet way to carry their NAA PUG. 22 magnum. Just remember that other model pistols like Sidewinders may not fit as well in this specific holster.

Buyer’s Guide

Important Features To Consider

When buying a Colt Peacemaker Holster, there are several features that should be considered:

  • Retention System: Ensure the holster has a good retention system to keep your gun secure and easily accessible.

  • Draw Stroke: The draw stroke should be smooth without any hiccups to ensure quick access in case of emergencies.

  • Comfort: The holster should be comfortable to wear and should not dig into your body or interfere with movement.

Material Quality

Colt Peacemaker Holsters-2

The materials used in crafting the holster are crucial. High-quality leather or Kydex is recommended1 as it provides durability and robust construction.

Custom Fit

Colt Peacemaker Holsters come in various sizes due to the different variations of the gun. Ensure you get the correct size for your specific model

Consider Your Carry Style

Each individual has their own preference when it comes to carrying a firearm. Some carry openly, while others prefer concealed carry. Choose a holster that fits your preferred style of carry2.

Consider Your Clothing

Clothing plays a significant role in concealed carry. Depending on what you wear, certain types of holsters may not be suitable. Make sure the chosen holster will comfortably fit under your clothing and will not print3.

Colt Peacemaker Holsters-3

Law and Regulation Compliance

It’s essential to know and respect the laws regarding firearms where you live. Check if there are any specific regulations about using a Colt Peacemaker Holster in public4.

Price and Brand Reputation

While it’s not always true that you get what you pay for, quality holsters may come at a higher price point5.

Warranty and Return Policy

Always buy from reputable retailers who offer a good return policy and a clear warranty policy6.

Reviews and Ratings

Colt Peacemaker Holsters-4

Before making a purchase, take time to read reviews from existing customers7.

Maintenance and Care

Finally, consider how easy it is to clean and maintain your holster. Some materials are easier to clean than others, so this is another factor to consider when choosing your holster

[Leather Equipment](http: //www. leatherequipment. com/)[How to Choose a CCW Holster](http: //www. concealednation. org/how-to-choose-a-ccw-holster/)[Understanding Printing](http: //www. holstersinc. com/)[Concealed Carry Laws by State](http: //www. usacarry. com/how-to-concealed-carry-laws-by-state/)[How to Choose a Gun Holster](https: //www. youtube. com/watch? v=5Njr6QsjgQk)[Warranty and Return Policies](http: //www. holstersinc. com/)[Customer Reviews](http: //www. leatherequipment. com/)


What is a Colt Peacemaker?

A Colt Peacemaker, also known as the Single Action Army revolver, is a classic American cowboy revolver introduced by the Colt company in 1873. It was widely used by both civilians and law enforcement during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Colt Peacemaker Holsters-5

Why do I need a holster for my Colt Peacemaker?

A holster provides protection for your gun, ensuring the safe storage and transport of your firearm. It also helps prevent accidental firing, reduces wear and tear on the gun, and provides easy access when needed.

What types of Colt Peacemaker holsters are available?

There are several types of holsters designed specifically for the Colt Peacemaker, including:

  • Belt Holsters

  • Shoulder Holsters

  • Thigh Holsters

  • OWB (Outside the Waistband) Holsters

  • IWB (Inside the Waistband) Holsters

  • Pancake Holsters

How should I choose the right Colt Peacemaker holster?

Consider factors such as your intended use, personal preferences, and the level of concealment you desire. Also, make sure the holster is compatible with the size and model of your Colt Peacemaker, and offers proper retention to keep the gun securely in place.

What materials are commonly used for Colt Peacemaker holsters?

Colt Peacemaker Holsters-6

Common materials used for Colt Peacemaker holsters include:

  • Leather

  • Kydex

  • Nylon

  • Hybrid (leather and Kydex combined)

How do I properly fit my Colt Peacemaker in the holster?

Ensure that the gun fits securely within the holster with no wiggle room. The trigger guard should be fully covered to prevent accidental firing. If using a leather holster, allow time for the leather to mold and shape around your specific firearm.

Are there any safety features or considerations when using a Colt Peacemaker holster?

Yes, it’s essential to ensure that your holster offers proper retention to keep the gun secure. Additionally, avoid using holsters with flaps or covers that could impede a quick draw if needed. Always follow all safety precautions when handling your firearm, even when it’s in a holster.

How do I clean and maintain my Colt Peacemaker holster?

Clean and maintain your holster according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Generally, leather holsters should be cleaned with a damp cloth and conditioned regularly to prevent cracking and maintain their shape. Kydex or nylon holsters can be wiped clean with a damp cloth and air-dried.

How can I ensure the longevity of my Colt Peacemaker holster?

Regularly inspect your holster for signs of wear or damage, and promptly replace any worn or damaged components. Store your holster in a cool, dry place to prevent moisture damage. Additionally, always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for proper use and maintenance to extend the lifespan of your holster.

Can I use a Colt Peacemaker holster with other revolver models?

While some Colt Peacemaker holsters may be compatible with similar revolver models, it’s essential to verify compatibility before making a purchase. Holsters designed specifically for the Peacemaker may not fit other guns properly, potentially compromising safety and performance.

As an Amazon™ Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

    Back to Blog